Escape from Your State!

We have written about State Domicile before - https://htj.tax/?s=state+domicile
This is because we have many clients who "thought" that they exited their state only to be hit with big state tax bills years after they moved to another state - or moved abroad
Today, I want to talk about Illinois.  Within recent years, Illinois, like other states, has been considering tax increases.  So let us talk about some of the steps needed to move to Florida (my home state)

Who is an Illinois Resident?
If a taxpayer is an Illinois resident, they will remain so until taking affirmative steps to change residency. Illinois law defines an Illinois resident as follows:

…[a]n individual who is in Illinois for other than a temporary or transitory purpose during the taxable year or who is domiciled in Illinois but is absent from Illinois for a temporary or transitory purpose during the taxable year.6

For an Illinois resident moving to Florida who continues to reside in Illinois for part of the year, the focus will be on whether the individual is “domiciled” in Illinois. Illinois Department of Revenue Regulations define “domicile” as follows:

Domicile has been defined as the place where an individual has his or her true, fixed, permanent home and principal establishment, the place to which he or she intends to return whenever absent. It is the place in which an individual has voluntarily fixed the habitation of himself or herself and family, not for a mere special or limited purpose, but with the present intention of making a permanent home, until some unexpected event shall occur to induce adoption of some other permanent home. Another definition of “domicile” consistent with this is the place where an individual has fixed his or her habitation and has a permanent residence without any present intention of permanently moving. An individual can at any one time have but one domicile. If an individual has acquired a domicile at one place, he or she retains that domicile until he or she acquires another elsewhere.7

The Regulations do not provide a bright line test for determining whether an Illinois resident has changed his or her domicile. Phrases like “present intention” and “permanently moving” are fact-specific and invite litigation. Illinois courts have provided some clarity on the issue of domicile.

Cain v. Hamer.8
Cain v. Hamer (“Cain”) is a leading case that illuminates the balancing act a court will perform in determining whether an Illinois resident has changed his or her domicile to Florida. In November 1995, the Cains, husband and wife, executed and filed Florida “declaration of domicile” indicating change of domicile from Illinois to Florida and renouncing Illinois residency. The Cains obtained Florida drivers licenses, voter registration, Florida burial plots, and developed professional and medical relationships with Florida professionals. In August 2006, the Illinois Department of Revenue (“IDOR”) sent the Cains a notice of tax deficiency asserting that the Cains owed $1,842,582 in unpaid income tax, penalties and interest for the years 1996-2004.9 The Cains submitted payment under protest and filed a complaint seeking a declaration that they were not Illinois residents during the audit period. After considering cross motions for summary judgment, the circuit court ruled that the Cains were mere “seasonal visitors” not residents of Illinois.10 IDOR appealed the circuit court decision.

On appeal, the appellate court reviewed the circuit court decision de novo.11 The appellate court initially cited the Illinois Income Tax Act and corresponding regulations addressing “residency” and “domicile.” The appellate court noted that the most challenging aspect of the case was that the Cains split their time roughly equally between Florida and Illinois.12 For the entire period under audit, the Cains split their time as follows: 1,700 days in Florida, 1,666 in Illinois and 284 elsewhere.13

Because the Cains split their time nearly equally between Florida and Illinois, the court noted that, “…in some sense [the Cains] have maintained an intent to return to both Illinois and Florida for approximately half of their time throughout the relevant [audit] period.”14 Because a resident cannot intend to return to both states, the court relied upon the concept of domicile as an intended permanent home.15 Despite the fact that the Cains maintained contacts, memberships and real estate holdings in Illinois, the court noted that they changed their voter registration to Florida, paid Florid income taxes, obtained residency cards and driver’s licenses in Florida, and filed declaration of Florida residency. This was sufficient for the court to conclude that they wished to establish Florida as their permanent residence in 1995, even though they planned to keep ties in Illinois and have regular seasonal visits.16

Cain should provide some comfort for Illinoisans that plan to become Florida residents but want to continue spending some part of the year in Illinois. It is also clear from the fact-specific nature of Cain and the court’s careful balancing of factors, that the Cains narrowly escaped a significant Illinois tax liability. As a consequence, for those Illinoisans who wish to become Florida residents by moving to a condo in Naples while retaining the townhome in Hinsdale, they should take a number of “affirmative steps” to support their change of domicile to Florida.

Prudent Steps to Follow to Support Change of Domicile
The First few steps are critical: creating documentary evidence to establish Florida domicile. These steps include the following:

  • Purchasing or leasing a residence in Florida, using the new Florida address in the related deed or lease, and obtaining insurance in Florida on the residence or the property contained in the residence.
  • Informing the U.S. Postal Service, credit card companies, phone company, banks and financial institutions, physicians, social, civic, and religious organizations, family and friends of the change in address.
  • Applying for the Florida Homestead Real Property Tax Exemption using the address of the new residence. Note also that the Illinois homestead must be relinquished.
  • Signing and filing in the local court as soon as possible a Declaration of Domicile for Florida, which is an affidavit stating that one’s new domicile is Florida. Note that this is a Florida statutory requirement for establishing Florida domicile.17
  • Obtaining a Florida driver’s license and register motor vehicles and boats in Florida with Florida insurance.
  • Registering to vote in Florida.
  • Executing updated estate planning documents, such as wills, trusts, powers of attorney, and advance medical directives, stating a Florida domicile and using the Florida address in any other legal documents.
  • Using the Florida address in all federal documents such as passports, tax returns and tax related information documents, and Medicare and Social Security.
  • Filing tax returns in the appropriate national office for a Florida resident (for income tax returns currently this would be Austin, Texas, or Charlotte, North Carolina, depending on payment).
  • Keeping a contemporaneous log of daily whereabouts, including maintaining airline tickets showing arrival into Florida and departure from Florida.

Documenting Abandonment of Illinois Domicile
While the affirmative steps establishing Florida domicile are critical, equally important are the steps the individual should take showing he or she has abandoned Illinois domicile. These include principally the below:

  • Informing Illinois of relinquishment of old domicile by providing appropriate state agencies, such as the state taxing authorities, with the Declaration of Domicile for Florida.
  • Returning Illinois driver’s license and, if possible, assuring that any motor vehicles or boats are no longer registered in Illinois.
  • Renouncing the right to vote in Illinois (nor voting via absentee ballot).
  • Abstaining from using an Illinois address in legal documents.
  • Filing Illinois nonresident tax returns using Florida address.

Changing to Florida Domicile as the Center of Affairs
Perhaps the most challenging aspect of becoming a Florida resident is changing the center of affairs from Illinois to Florida. This is also an area that will trip up many taxpayers even if they have followed the other procedural requirements outlined above because they may not be able to comply with these best practices without disrupting family or social ties. A list of the primary steps that individuals should take are as follows:

Home
First and most obvious spend as much time as possible in the Florida home – at least six months. Reside in the Florida home.

Family
Have holidays with family at the Florida home. The more family activities in Florida with Florida residents in the family, the stronger the indicator that Florida is one’s domicile. Purchase a burial plot in Florida.

Property
Move as much property as possible to Florida, especially property that may be considered near and dear to one’s heart, and secure a Florida safe deposit box to store valuable items and important documents. Open bank and financial accounts in Florida.

Social
Join social clubs in Florida and be active in those clubs. Maintain friends in Florida. Purchase memberships or season tickets to theaters, sports teams, museums, and other local performance-related activities in Florida.

Civic
Vote in Florida, in person. Donate to political campaigns for Florida’s state and local offices. Attend and donate to religious organizations in Florida. Volunteer with Florida organizations and charities, and donate to them.

Healthcare
Obtain a healthcare provider in Florida.

Business
If still actively working, work as much time as possible in Florida. Establish a principal place of business in Florida.

As Cain illustrates, a person’s subjective intent determines domicile for legal purposes. However, tax authorities place great weight on the above checklist items. Remember, for those taxpayers who do not plan their exit carefully, Illinois and its taxing authorities will be vigilant about welcoming them “home.”

6. IL Comp. Stat. Ann. 5/1501(a)(20) (West 2012).

7. IL Admin. Code Tit. 86 §100.3020(b) (2013).
8. 2012 IL App (1st) 112833, 975 N.E. 2d 321.
9. Id. 975 N.E. 2d at 2.
10. Id. 975 N.E. 2d at 3.
11. Id. 1 975 N.E. 2d at 4.
12. Id. 975 N.E. 2d at 5.
13. Id. 975 N.E. 2d at 7.
14. Id. 975 N.E. 2d at 8.
15. Id. 975 N.E. 2d at 8.
16. Id. 975 N.E. 2d at 9.
17. Fla. Stat. §222.17 (2019).

Related Posts