Non – Americans (Non-Residents Non-Citizens or NRNCs) Should Be Careful With US Structures
On this page
There is no shortage of service providers promoting US structures for non-Americans. I have cautioned against this before-
https://htj.tax/2024/10/are-us-asset-protection-and-estate-planning-structures-right-for-non-resident-aliens/.
Beyond Pasquantino v. United States and the FIFA case which I reference in the link above, there’s now a new case in Guyana.
Down in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, federal prosecutors have unsealed an indictment that should send a ripple through the international private client and global business community. While Miami dockets frequently make headlines for high-profile regional figures, the November 2025 indictment of Guyanese opposition leader Azruddin Mohamed and his father, Nazar Mohamed, is an extraordinary case study in the long-arm reach of U.S. criminal enforcement.
The Department of Justice is charging them not with evading U.S. taxes, but with defrauding the Guyanese government of taxes and royalties.
To pull this off, the DOJ reached deep into its playbook to resurrect an aggressive, rarely used legal theory: the Pasquantino doctrine.
The Backdrop: Gold, Supercars, and Guyanese Politics
To understand the stakes, you have to look at the players. In Guyana—an economy transformed over the last few years into one of the world’s fastest-growing oil frontiers—the Mohamed family built an empire as the country’s dominant gold traders and exporters.
The elder Nazar built the business from the ground up, while his son Azruddin cultivated a high-profile persona complete with exotic car collections and splashy philanthropy. In 2024, the U.S. State Department slapped sanctions on them alleging public corruption.
Undeterred, Azruddin entered the political arena in 2025. He launched a populist campaign as an outsider, finished second in the presidential race, and stepped up as Guyana’s parliamentary opposition leader. A centerpiece of his platform? A controversial pledge to renegotiate Guyana’s massive offshore oil contracts with ExxonMobil.
Two months after the election, the DOJ dropped a federal indictment in Miami. Both men were arrested in Guyana on U.S. extradition requests and are currently out on bond, contesting extradition in Guyanese courts while Azruddin remains in Parliament.
The Alleged Scheme: How Gold Flowed Through Florida
The core of the DOJ’s case is that the Mohameds evaded an estimated $50 million in Guyanese taxes, duties, and royalties on gold destined for buyers in Dubai.
Where does the United States come in? Miami was the transit hub.
According to federal prosecutors, the scheme worked across three operational steps:
- The Legit Run: The Mohameds exported a legitimate shipment of gold from Guyana, paying all local customs duties and royalties. Guyanese revenue authorities affixed official customs control seals to the cargo crates. The gold stopped in Miami en route to Dubai, with the Mohameds wiring payments to Miami-based transport and logistics firms.
- The Return Loop: In Dubai, the crates were allegedly unpacked without breaking the official Guyanese seals. The empty, still-sealed crates were then shipped right back through Miami via an American commercial carrier to the Mohameds in Guyana.
- The Recycled Seals: Back in Guyana, the Mohameds allegedly loaded untaxed gold into the reused crates, presented the old customs paperwork showing duties were “already paid,” and shipped the cargo back out to Dubai. Once again, the shipments transited through Miami, with coordinating emails and wire transfers bouncing across U.S. telecommunications systems.
The Mechanics: What Is the Pasquantino Theory?
To non-lawyers, charging foreign citizens for evading foreign taxes through a foreign transaction sounds like pure jurisdictional overreach. But here is the technical nuance: technically, the DOJ is not prosecuting foreign tax evasion.
They are prosecuting mail and wire fraud (18 U.S.C. §§ 1341 & 1343).
In Pasquantino v. United States (2005), the U.S. Supreme Court reviewed a case where individuals in New York used Maryland truckers to smuggle liquor into Canada to dodge Canadian excise taxes. Because the conspirators made interstate phone calls to organize the smuggling runs, the DOJ charged them with U.S. wire fraud: executing a scheme to defraud a victim of money using U.S. communications wires.
The victim happened to be the Canadian government, and the money happened to be unpaid excise tax.
The Supreme Court upheld the convictions, ruling that:
- Foreign tax revenue constitutes “property” within the scope of the federal wire fraud statute.
- The common-law “revenue rule” does not prevent the U.S. government from prosecuting fraudulent uses of domestic communications wires within its own borders.
Back in 2005, many of us in the cross-border tax world wondered if Pasquantino would open the floodgates for federal prosecutors to police global tax compliance via the U.S. financial system. It didn’t. The doctrine was narrowed, global cooperation frameworks (like FATCA, CRS, and bilateral MLATs) took precedence, and Pasquantino sat mostly dormant as a legal oddity. Between 2005 and 2024, only a single federal case used it as the primary liability theory.
Until now.
The Legal Battle Ahead: Two Fronts
If the Mohameds are extradited to Florida, expect two aggressive lines of defense.
1. Testing the Outer Limits of Jurisdiction
In the original Pasquantino case, the defendants were based on U.S. soil and executed the core of the scheme domestically. In Mohamed, neither the seller (Guyana), nor the buyer (Dubai), nor the alleged victim (the Guyanese treasury) is American.
The U.S. connection rests entirely on:
- Transit through a Florida logistics waypoint.
- Communications with Miami freight forwarders.
- The physical shipment of empty wooden crates through U.S. interstate couriers.
The defense will lean heavily on Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s classic dissent in Pasquantino, where she warned that the majority ascribed an “exorbitant scope” to the wire fraud statute. They will argue that transforming a foreign customs dispute into a U.S. federal felony simply because crates touched down at Miami International Airport stretches federal jurisdiction beyond recognition.
The DOJ’s counter? The plain language of the statute applies: the physical instrumentalities of an alleged $50 million fraud moved directly across U.S. soil.
2. The “Stalking Horse” Defense (Vindictive Prosecution)
Azruddin Mohamed has publicly claimed the charges are politically manufactured, alleging collusion between the current Guyanese administration, international oil conglomerates, and U.S. authorities to sideline him after his presidential run.
In federal court, this translates into a motion to dismiss for vindictive prosecution.
Under U.S. legal precedent, establishing vindictive prosecution requires proving two elements:
- The prosecutor harbored actual animus—or was used as a “stalking horse” by an outside party harboring that animus.
- The defendant would not have faced prosecution but for that animus.
While a foreign government could theoretically act as the animus-driven third party behind a stalking-horse claim, winning this motion in federal court is notoriously difficult. As long as the DOJ presents standard, objective evidence of wire and logistics fraud, federal courts will not dismiss the indictment.
Practical Takeaways for Global Entrepreneurs and Family Offices
This case serves as a stark reminder of fundamental principles we stress daily at HTJ.tax:
- The U.S. Logistics and Financial System Creates Nexus: You do not need to be a U.S. citizen, hold a green card, or maintain a U.S. operating company to fall under federal scrutiny. Utilizing U.S.-based freight forwarders, domestic couriers, U.S. dollar clearing rails, or U.S.-hosted cloud infrastructure can establish the jurisdictional hook for wire and mail fraud.
- Mail and Wire Fraud Remain the DOJ’s Swiss Army Knife: When substantive tax codes or treaty boundaries present hurdles, federal prosecutors look to the broad wording of Title 18 fraud statutes.
- Geopolitical Profile Magnifies Scrutiny: High-net-worth cross-border operators in extractive industries (gold, commodities, energy) who transition into local politics operate under an intense regulatory microscope. Cross-border structural compliance must be airtight.
Be careful out there….
Looking for an international tax service?
We’re always here to help. Don’t hesitate to get in touch.
Talk to an expert
